Princess Polly vs Oh Polly: Price, Sizing, Shipping and Returns
By LUNETTE Style DeskShare
On published terms, Princess Polly is the lower-priced, more flexible choice: a $75 dress median against $165 at Oh Polly in our 250-product sample, free shipping from $50 against $160, and 30 days to return against 7 days for a refund. Oh Polly offers more size options at the top end in our sample. We have not tested the clothes.
Disclosure: LUNETTE sells dresses, so we compete with the stores below. Every competitor figure is dated and linked to that store's own page, and we say where they are ahead of us.
Verdict table
| Princess Polly | Oh Polly | Edge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dress price (sample median) | $75 | $165 | Princess Polly |
| Free standard shipping from | $50 ($6.99 under) | $160 (as shown in the cart) | Princess Polly |
| Delivery | 4 to 8 business days, US distribution center | Not verified | Princess Polly (verified) |
| Return window | 30 days from delivery | 7 days refund, 14 days exchange, 28 days store credit | Princess Polly |
| Return cost | Original postage not refunded | $12.99 fee on refunds ($9.99 via Happy Returns) | Depends on your case |
| Size options (sample) | US 0 to 16 | XXS to XXL, some single size | Even |
Prices
We read each store's public product feed on 17 October 2026 and took the lowest variant price of dresses among the top 250 products. It is a sample of what each store lists at the top, so treat medians as a guide.
| Dresses in sample | Range | Median | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Princess Polly | 53 | $40 to $99 | $75 |
| Oh Polly | 68 | $45 to $245 | $165 |
The 2 brands start at similar prices, $40 and $45, but Oh Polly's range runs much higher.
Sizes
Princess Polly's most common size options in the sample were US 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14 and 16. Oh Polly's were XXS to XXL plus single-size items. The numbers use different systems, so compare each brand's chart against your measurements before ordering.
Shipping and returns
- Princess Polly: standard shipping is 4 to 8 business days from a US distribution center; free on orders over $50, $6.99 under $50. Returns within 30 days of delivery for exchange, gift card or refund; items must be sent back within 7 days of submitting the return, and original postage is not refunded.
- Oh Polly: free standard shipping starts at $160 per the US cart banner. Refund within 7 days of delivery, exchange within 14 days, store credit up to 28 days; $12.99 is deducted from a refund ($9.99 via Happy Returns).
Princess Polly's own shipping page prints 2 different under-$50 shipping figures, so we cite only the $50 threshold as the stable number.
Which one for which occasion
- Event inside 2 weeks: Princess Polly, since delivery times are published and shorter than our own.
- Budget under $100: Princess Polly, with a $99 sample maximum.
- A higher-priced dress and a smaller risk of return: compare Oh Polly's current prices with its 7-day window in mind.
Customer-service ratings move daily, so read recent reviews for both on a neutral site.
Another option: LUNETTE
If price is the main thing, LUNETTE's dresses ran from $28.99 to $67.99 on 17 October 2026. For example, the Halter Neck Satin A-Line Mini Dress ($43.99), a short satin halter with a flared skirt. The honest trade-offs: a 14-day return window against Princess Polly's 30, no direct exchanges, US-only shipping, 5 to 9 business days of delivery after 1 to 3 days of processing, and no customer reviews yet.
Read next: Meshki vs Oh Polly, brands like Princess Polly and Oh Polly alternatives. See the dresses collection and our returns policy.
FAQ
Is Princess Polly cheaper than Oh Polly?
In the top 250 products each store listed on 17 October 2026, Princess Polly's dress median was $75 (53 dresses, $40 to $99) and Oh Polly's was $165 (68 dresses, $45 to $245). Princess Polly was cheaper in this sample.
Which ships faster, Princess Polly or Oh Polly?
Princess Polly's shipping page lists standard shipping at 4 to 8 business days from a US distribution center. We could not verify Oh Polly's delivery times because its shipping page returned a not-found error on 17 October 2026.
Which has the better return policy?
Princess Polly gives 30 days from delivery for an exchange, gift card or refund. Oh Polly gives 7 days for a refund, 14 for an exchange and 28 for store credit, with a $12.99 fee on refunds. On the published terms Princess Polly is more flexible, though it does not refund original postage.
Is Princess Polly or Oh Polly better quality?
We have not tested either, so we make no quality claim. This guide compares price, shipping, sizes and return terms only.
Is there a lower-priced option than both?
LUNETTE's 20 dresses ran from $28.99 to $67.99 on 17 October 2026. Our returns window is shorter (14 days), we do not offer direct exchanges, and we ship only within the US.
Sources and how we checked
- Princess Polly storefront product feed (top 250 products), retrieved 17 October 2026
- Princess Polly shipping page, retrieved 17 October 2026
- Princess Polly returns page, retrieved 17 October 2026
- Oh Polly storefront product feed (top 250 products), retrieved 17 October 2026
- Oh Polly US storefront (cart free-shipping banner), retrieved 17 October 2026
- Oh Polly return policy, retrieved 17 October 2026
- LUNETTE Shipping and Delivery page, retrieved 17 October 2026
- LUNETTE Returns and Refunds page, retrieved 17 October 2026
- LUNETTE Size Guide, retrieved 17 October 2026
Written by the LUNETTE Style Desk for lunettewoman.com (also written as Lunette Woman), a US online women's fashion store. Prices and policies change: check the linked pages before you order.